GOP Effort Falls Short

Columnist's post-election wrap up includes a mea culpa.

What I Got Right: The Electoral College numbers.

What Else I Got Right: Not much.

With very little time to process it and absolutely no time to dig through exit poll cross tabs, here’s what I saw last night.

First, while I got the Electoral College vote numbers almost exactly right, I got the candidate completely wrong. As predicted, many swing states were close, but in the end almost everyone one broke for the incumbent.

From a political analysis point of view, this is a surprise for many reasons. Traditionally, when the incumbent has approval ratings as low as Barack Obama’s, he loses. Traditionally, an election like this brings greater turnout from the opposition. Traditionally, late-deciders always break for the challenger. Tradition was blown to pieces last night.

What pundits and talking heads will debate for the next several weeks will be why. Unemployment remains near 8 percent and job creation isn’t keeping up with population growth, the President’s “signature” legislation continues to be widely unpopular, more Americans continue to live in poverty, Americans now carry more debt per capita than the citizens of Greece, the President continues to plan huge spending and debt increases and America continues on the path to economic collapse. And yet the American people chose four more years.

I call it a complete communications breakdown. The Democratic effort was extremely effective at framing the debate, making a huge election about small things. No matter where you stand politically, there is no denying that on every issue that has come up in the general election, the mainstream media protected and promoted the President, including but not limited to underperforming jobs numbers and what will eventually turn into the political scandal of our lifetimes, the assassination of four Americans in an unprotected Consulate in Benghazi. And the Republican effort, while extremely well-organized and fueled by great enthusiasm, fell short of connecting the dots and closing the deal.

In New Hampshire races, there is no question that the results of the gubernatorial race impacted the entire ticket. Again, the Democratic effort was successful at diverting the attention from $900 million deficits, devastating taxation and crushing growth of government to talk instead about fabricated charges and small ideas.

But in the end, it is up to the candidates and the party to articulate their message. While we can identify many influences on how the message was framed, the ultimate responsibility for communicating with voters belongs to the candidate. Campaigns are not birthday parties and politics is not children’s play. It is a tough business that requires skill, discipline and dedication to a higher purpose. If you are going to succeed and connect with voters, you need a strong and honest message and both the ability and willingness to take on all comers, whether it is a dishonest opponent or a biased press.

I will write more about the consequences this election will have on future generations later, but for now, there are some hard lessons to be learned here; lessons about organization, turnout and voter insecurity.

A note of caution, however, to Democrats in general and President Obama in particular: while the Electoral College may look like a landslide, the popular vote was not. If the next four years look very much like the last four years, the results in 2016 will be dramatically different.

Proud Conservative November 15, 2012 at 10:47 PM
Sort of like "It's Bush's fault", eh?
Proud Conservative November 16, 2012 at 12:28 AM
I'm sure that's true, Tammy. But that does not excuse them for breaking the law any more than the noble thought of providing Christmas gifts for your family excuses robbing a bank. It's our country, not theirs. We can make whatever laws we want regarding entry into the country. Nothing says we must or should change our procedures to accommodate the wishes of would-be criminals. I have absolutely no sympathy for illegal immigrants regardless of their motive for coming here and personally I feel each and every one of them should be deported and denied reentry.
LJoel Hackbart November 18, 2012 at 04:11 AM
A pure popular vote would force the campaigns to stop in big cities and dense populations only. This would tend to favor democrats. Be careful what you wish for repubs.
LJoel Hackbart November 18, 2012 at 04:39 AM
Tell poor Mrs. Horn. The rescue of the American Auto industry was no small thing. Tell poor Mrs., Horn. The stimulus and actions taken by the Obama Administration to bring an economy in unimaginable freefall back from the brink is no small thing. Tell poor Mrs., Horn getting Bin Laden is no small thing. Tell Mrs. Horn that 5.4 million private sector jobs created is no small thing. Tell Mrs. Horn Statements like" "I struggled with it myself for a long time, but I came to realize that life is that gift from God, and I think even when life begins in that horrible situation of rape, that it is something God intended to happen." are not small things when they become common place in GOP circles. Tell Mrs. Horn It is not a small thing that the American people saw through the barrage of Romney lies. The final desperate lie of Romney wildly claiming that Jeep was moving to China backfired in Ohio and clinched that state for Obama. Tell Mrs. Horn that Benghazi is not the biggest scandal of our lifetime. Watergate. Iran Contra. Weapons of mass destruction. Illegal torture. Benghazi is not a scandal at all no matter how hard the far right is trying to manufacture one. Mrs. Horn’s statements here are just as absurd as her election predictions.
LJoel Hackbart November 18, 2012 at 04:48 AM
Bushes "victory" in 2000 {Gore won the popular vote] was called a "mandate" Bushes "victory"[despite the voting irregularities in Ohio} was called a "mandate" by the republicans. But a near 3 million vote victory by Obama? Oh no. Not a mandate. No way. No how. It was way too close to say that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »